What happened in Minneapolis a few weeks ago is an outright tragedy. Ten times as many agents as were deployed to Chicago. Neighborhoods invaded by armed, masked agents. Firearms and chemical agents deployed at schools. It’s sickening enough and needed to stop long before Alex Pretti, Renee Good, and others were killed by these agents.
This community doesn’t deserve this shit. No community does.
The people with the power to dispatch these agents have done nothing to make these communities safer. Indeed, they and their defenders neglect the basic humanity, liberty, and civil rights of the victims.
I remember when Minnesota passed the Personal Protection Act. Tim Pawlenty, governor at the time, said it would allow “the most law abiding of citizens” to fully exercise their rights. His legislative leadership dismissed “fearmongering” counter arguments under the same premise.
At the time of Minnesota’s concealed carry law, there was a opponents of the legislation largely assumed good faith: Its supporters simply had a different, genuine, perspective about how to solve a problem. It certainly seems like the people who made those arguments 23 years ago have suddenly reversed course.
Or maybe not so suddenly. Several police-involved shooting victims were executed on the premise that they had a gun (Philando Castile) or other arms (George Floyd had a knife) legally on their person — not brandished, stowed. All of the defenders of police in these shootings conveniently forget that law enforcement, especially federal, is the government. Killing a suspect is extra-judicial execution! Is this not exactly the kind of tyranny an armed public is meant to protect us from?
Alex Pretti is the case in point. The man was an ICU nurse who legally carried a weapon on the street until he was pepper sprayed, tackled, disarmed, and executed (in that order). Every indoor space around where Pretti was executed could ban concealed firearms on the premises but he’d still have the right to carry it in the middle of the street, even at a protest. The government has no right to disarm you unless you are detained.
Pretti was not detained, yet he was disarmed. He was disarmed, yet he was nonetheless executed. Where are the 2A supporters rushing to defend this law-abiding citizen’s civil rights?
They’re nowhere.
Steven Miller called him an assassin. Greg Bovino said he needed to be executed because he wanted to “massacre law enforcement.” (Pretti had his hands up before he was taken down.)
Kristi Noem said “I don’t know of any peaceful protester that shows up with a gun and ammunition rather than a sign.” Kash Patel said something similar. JD Vance amplified both of them. (Here’s one. Here’s another. Oh, and here’s a whole bunch! Tony Cornish used to carry on the floor of the MN House.)
Gun Owners of America and the leader of Tennessee’s GOP legislature both defended the victim in the press. But neither seems to have said much since. (Maybe MPR wants to revise that headline from “backlash” to “tepid disagreement.”)
If they had an ounce of courage, they’d demand investigations about unlawful search-and-seizure of a lawful citizen’s firearm by the federal government.
They’d insist on cooperation with Minnesota’s Bureau of Criminal Apprehension to understand how the state’s law was broken.
They’d mobilize their base in defense of the summary execution of someone exercising his 2nd Amendment rights.
None of this has happened.
None of that will happen because all of the people with the power to do it are cowards for whom Constitutional rights only apply to people who use them correctly. They seek only to preserve their own power through fear and coercion.
I don’t think “more guns” is a solution to any problem, or that the 2nd Amendment gives an unlimited personal right to possess firearms.
If it were up to me, ICE and Border Patrol agents wouldn’t be allowed to carry them for most operations. Police wouldn’t be permitted to carry them for most routine house and welfare calls. We’d have ongoing buy-back programs to get unwanted and illegal weapons off the streets.
But laws like MN’s Personal Protection Act are premised on more guns as the only thing standing between freedom and a Stalinist state where the government can just pull law-abiding citizens off the street under false pretenses and ship them to gulags across the country. The same people who supported and defended these laws over the last several decades left out the part about gulags and execution being totally appropriate if you’re on the wrong side of their politics.
For their part, the Democrats could do more than send a fucking text message. They should be in the streets, demanding justice, and showing the public a better way forward. Some are doing this, too many are not.
If you want to see courage, go to the streets of Minneapolis and ask how you can help.
























